Find one work that you know and fill out
the grid below by writing your brief judgement in the appropriate column. Use
the questions in number 4 to guide you and then complete the paragraph provided
as a model of your appreciation report on a work.
No.
|
Title & Author
|
Psychological Truth
|
Originality
|
Craftmanship
|
Consciousness of Moral Value
|
1.
|
· Title :
Ayat-ayat
Cinta
· Author:
Habiburrahman El Shirazy
|
-This novel is reasonably developed.
-It tells us about the relationship between human
and human & human with their God.
-It is not made just anything, but there are some true
sources.
|
-This novel is originally made by Habiburrahman El
Shirazy, a post-graduated scholar from Al-Azhar University in Cairo, Egypt
and be the best seller novel.
|
-The author use the simply language which are
unique, touching, have a religion nuance and about romantic love.
-He reveals his feelings and ideas throughout
uncommon setting and plot, make a story which bundled with a different
background and culture.
|
-This story gives us an example of a good marriage
which appropriate with Islamic law.
-We can learn about Egypt’s culture, norms and
social condition at there without visit the place directly.
-It is be able to be religious spreader media for
the members of Islamic community in the world.
-This story teaches us how important to be a good
person with a good behavior and also learning us to understand deeply about
the meaning of life & love.
|
This work is entitled
Ayat-ayat Cinta and written by Habiburrahman El Shirazy. It is published in December
2004 by January 2008 in Jakarta.
My general comment about
the book is Interesting !
The following is some
detailed quality I found in the work.
First, when I read it I feel that the story is reasonably developed. It talks
about a love story between two humans that have a different background. One is an
Indonesian man having an opportunity to study abroad in Cairo, Egypt and the
second one is a student from Cairo too. They are falling in love each other and
then doing a marriage. Although they have to face an unfair condition in the
middle of their love journey but finally they could solve it wisely based on
Islamic law. Several things that built the psychological truth are :
1. This novel is reasonably developed
because it contains of our daily life about love, religion, social, politic and
culture.
2. It tells us about the relationship
between human and human & human with their God which consists some
conflicts that usually happen.
3. It is not made just anything, but
there are some true sources. There are from Islamic book, hadist and holy
qur’an which are being a true sources.
Besides
However, this novel’s is
not only consists of humans love theme with other but also humans love theme
with their God that are implemented in our daily life. So, it bundles love
novel, cultural novel and Islamic novel into the one story. We can learn about
Egypt’s culture, norms and social condition at there without visit the place
directly.
Secondly, this work indicates high originality. It is not about the theme but the
way this work is presented. I think the terms belong to the writer’s own
creation because he represents the true habitual activities in Cairo seems like
he knows all the cultural tradition at there (I was surprise to see many proud
comments and responses about this novel which makes me realize that I was a
lucky girl because I have choose a right choice for reading this novel). In
addition, it teaches me that we have to see a problem from the different side,
we have to face our problems calmly, always put effort to solve it, and hand
the decision over to God. I think I have never read the expressions before
(This makes me conclude that this work offers new experience to me).
Thirdly, when
I read this work I got a lot of impression in the creativity of the author. The author use the simply language
which are unique, touching, have a religion nuance and about romantic love. The most interesting thing is the
story especially tell us about Islamic religion’s problem which comes in the
story. For examples : the Islamic law about polygamy, how to be a good human
who near with their God and what we have to do in such condition. This story
gives us an example of a good marriage which appropriate with Islamic law. It
was explaining the answer of its problem, so it is not making us confused and easy
to understand the content.
This work really teaches
me about life. It gives enough lesson about life in a real life that actually makes
us aware that we have not enough knowledge about Islamic religion. So we have
to deepen our Islamic knowledge by learn more. This novel also tells us about
reality of life that fulfill with many conflicts we cannot run from it. They
will teach us how important to be a good person with a good behavior and also
learn us to understand deeply about the meaning of life & love. It is also
be able to be religious spreader media for the members of Islamic community in
the world.
I think I agree about it.
No comments:
Post a Comment